Update: Pikmin 4 on Switch 2 gets a 1.9 user score and is called a 'paid downgrade'

Update: the Switch 2 edition of Pikmin 4, released on Thursday, November 12, with the Dandori Academy mode, is being review-bombed by users on Metacritic: the user score sits at 1.9 out of 10 — a sharp drop from the original game’s 8.9. Geekiki covered the edition’s launch; it sells as a $9.99 upgrade pack for players who already own the game on Switch.

According to GameRant, the score is based on 306 user reviews. Polygon, which reported the backlash on Monday (11/16), describes the edition as the target of a wave of fan criticism calling it a “paid downgrade”.

What players are complaining about

The main complaints are about performance: players report frame rate drops and longer load times than in the original version. One review cited by Polygon claims load times went from “six seconds to 30+ seconds” and the frame rate from “a consistent 30 FPS to an inconsistent 30 FPS”. Another review sums it up as “actively makes the game worse”, also citing glitches and hitching.

There is also criticism of the new content: for some players, the Dandori Academy stages are repetitive and reuse areas from the main story.

What was praised

Not everything was criticized: the Switch 2 version runs at a higher resolution, and the voice commands for Oatchi, the space dog, were well received by some players.

The Reddit reaction and what the score means

On the Pikmin subreddit, the reaction was more measured: some users called the scores overblown — “0.6 is a score I’d only give to a game that is sub-functional”, one of them wrote — while others argued that the new stages, despite reusing maps, bring enemy placements and changes that set them apart.

Some context is in order: Metacritic’s user score is self-reported and can be inflated by coordinated campaigns — a “review bombing” — so 1.9 out of 10 measures the dissatisfaction of those who went to rate it, not an objective measure of quality. Polygon’s report does not record a response from Nintendo to the criticism.

Fans worried about the series’ future point out that the edition’s light changes, compared with other Switch 2 games, may signal that Pikmin is not among Nintendo’s top priorities — although Pikmin 5 has not been announced and the recently announced animated shorts give fans something to look forward to.

Sources

Image: official artwork of Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy, featuring colorful Pikmin, Oatchi and the demo-available badge. Artwork: Nintendo.

Transparency note: this article was produced with the assistance of artificial intelligence, based on public posts on X and reporting on the internet, and reviewed against the cited sources. Please consult the original sources to confirm the information.

Por Muse